|
Some thoughts on pricing, and shopping for art on the internet
Dear friends,
I am sometimes asked how I determine value for a particular piece
of art in my inventory. It is an art more than a science to know
fair market value. I tell people, if my prices were too high I could
not remain in business because no one would buy from me, and conversely,
if my prices were too low I would go out of business because my
business would not support itself. There is an organic "right"
price for a piece of art. A bargain-priced piece of art likely has
a problem.
The internet has made a world of information available, although
not all of it is accurate. One may find themselves in a transaction
with someone whom they know little about and have never met. One
should be aware that not all dealers are totally honest in their
descriptions and offerings and that a little information can be
a dangerous thing. Sometimes what is shown and described online
is not the same item that arrives at your door wrapped in brown
paper.
I was recently scolded by a woman who had never collected prints
before but who assured me that my prices on a particular item were
"too high". I was mildly amused to find out that she had
not yet actually examined any artwork first-hand and had only compared
price lists that she found online.
Unlike shopping for a book or a CD on-line, antique prints are
not a commodity. A seasoned collector would happily select a higher-priced
example of the same print if it had superb vintage color, pristine
condition, interesting provenance, untrimmed margins, a period frame
or many, many other reasons.
In particular, lately there has been a rash of newly-colored McKenney
and Hall and Karl Bodmer Indian portraits offered at bargain prices
online. Some of these are "train wrecks" that have been
completely bleached, stripped and re-colored. Many were originally
issued in black and white and have been colored only recently. If
one examines the subscriber records for the Bodmer atlas, it becomes
obvious that only about a third of the prints were originally issued
with color. Because we almost never see a black and white Bodmer,
it is obvious that about two-thirds of the Bodmer's on the market
are newly colored. Some of my clients collect only the black and
whites because they are so scarce and because they have not been
tampered with in any way.
We welcome new collectors and are delighted to work with you to
understand the nuance of these pieces. That is why we aren't a "click-and-shop"
site. We have chosen not to publish some of our prices on line-but
hope you will phone us tollfree as we would be delighted to learn
more about your interests and quote you on any items you are considering.
Best regards,
Tam O'Neill
|